LAW

How To Deal With Employees Refusing to Sign New Employment Contracts

Fact-checked
How To Deal With Employees Refusing to Sign New Employment Contracts

Sometimes employers will require changes to employment contracts whether that be due to changes to their business operations, new responsibilities, salary changes or new company policies. As such whilst providing clarifications there may be situations where an employee is unwilling to sign the new employment contracts. Employees may have concerns around changes to their salary, work conditions, termination clauses and their overall rights within their current employment contract. When deliberately considering how to deal with this situation employers should be careful not to cause any unnecessary conflict or legal claims. Having a structured process will help you to identify what your employee’s concerns are whilst still knowing you are meeting your contractual and legal obligations.

Reviewing the Existing Employment Agreement

Prior to writing to your employee you should familiarize yourself with the updating clauses within their existing employment contract. This will help you to determine whether the changes are to provide clarity rather than a substantial change. You should check where the changes are to; salary, responsibilities, hours of work, benefits, termination and restrictive covenants. This will help you understand what your employee may have already agreed to within their contract.

You should also consider what changes are being made to their current contractual rights and whether any employment laws apply. Any large unilateral changes to fundamental elements within their employment contract may raise legal issues for you such as constructive dismissal within the province of Ontario. It is not wise to assume your employees will automatically agree to the new terms just because they are carrying on with their role following being presented with the new contracts. You should consider speaking to Employment Lawyer Toronto. This can help to give you peace of mind around the potential legal issues.

Understanding Employee Concerns

When an employee refuses to sign new employment contracts you should try and identify why. Some people refuse to sign as they feel they are losing benefits within their role, taking on more responsibilities or may feel they are being restricted. Others may simply want more time to understand what is being asked of them within the legal wording. Giving them the opportunity to explain will help to identify any misunderstandings and can highlight clauses that need further clarification.

You should encourage them to show you exactly where they are having problems. Talking through any issues can help to find some compromise around the new terms. Managers should keep their tone professional at all times and not make any threats. This can help to reduce any tension between the two parties.

Providing Clear Explanations of Proposed Changes

Start by giving your employee some clear reasons for why you wish to provide them with updated contracts. Explain how the changes within your business have meant you need these changes, this might include changes in your hierarchy, salary or new responsibilities. This will give your employee a clear insight into why you require them to sign the contracts. This will also reduce any assumptions that they may make that you are trying to take away any of their existing rights.

Ensure you provide a copy of the newly updated contract in writing. Give them plenty of time to look through this. By highlighting any key changes to the contract they will make it easier for them to compare. Try not to rely on only verbal explanations. People can become confused and argue what was actually discussed. It will be much clearer and they will be able to get independent legal advice.

Maintaining Accurate Records of Discussions

Should your employee refuse to sign agreeing to an updated employment contract you should record the details of when you provided them with the new document, what information you explained and any concerns they had. Summary of meetings and emails can all help to show how you dealt with the situation. This can be beneficial to know if any future disagreements occur around their contractual responsibilities.

Ensure any documentation provided is clear and does not suggest they are being punished for refusing to sign new contract terms. Make sure you set out clearly that this is a separate issue to any performance or conduct issues. This will ensure that any unrelated issues within the business are not brought into a contractual dispute. An Employment lawyer can also review the documentation and identify if any further communication or legal issues need to be considered.

Considering Negotiation and Alternative Arrangements

If they are raising reasonable concerns you may want to agree to compromise some clauses. This may include changing their responsibilities, salary, notice periods or specific wording around their restrictions. Whilst you may not be able to agree to all of the changes you can look at what specific concerns they have. This can help to identify what is key to them and what can be changed.

However, you should not make any major changes unless they have agreed to them legally. Depending on their existing contract and the nature of the changes there may be something needing to be considered such as fresh consideration. Make sure you get the correct legal advice prior to assuming they have agreed to the new terms due to them continuing in their role.

Conclusion

Overall to deal with employees refusing to sign new employment contracts you should be careful and have a structured process. You should identify what existing contractual obligations you have, understand their concerns, give clear reasons for the requested changes and record accurately. You may be able to compromise to overcome any disagreements but still meet your key business requirements. Speaking to an employment lawyer (which you can trust in Toronto) can help to reduce any legal risk and help you to make an informed decision when making substantial changes to any contracts.

Read More From the LAW desk