Listen to this article now

In recent years, the rise of buy now, pay later (BNPL) services has transformed the way consumers make purchases, offering a convenient alternative to traditional credit cards. With the growing popularity of BNPL companies, Consumer Reports, a trusted consumer advocacy organization, has conducted extensive research and analysis to evaluate and rank these companies. In this article, we will delve into Consumer Reports’ methodology and discuss how they ranked the buy now, pay later companies.

Understanding Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)

Before delving into the ranking process, it’s important to grasp the concept of buy now, pay later services. BNPL allows consumers to make purchases and split the payment into interest-free installments over a specific period. It offers a flexible payment option without the need for a traditional credit card or incurring high-interest charges.

Consumer Reports’ Methodology

Consumer Reports employs a rigorous methodology to assess and rank buy now, pay later companies. Their evaluation involves a comprehensive analysis of various factors to determine the best BNPL services in terms of transparency, customer satisfaction, security, and overall value for consumers. Some key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Transparency: Consumer Reports assesses the transparency of BNPL companies, evaluating their terms and conditions, fees, and any hidden charges. Clear and easily understandable information is crucial to ensure consumers make informed decisions.
  • Consumer Feedback: The organization considers consumer feedback to gauge overall customer satisfaction. They analyze reviews, ratings, and complaints to understand the experiences of real users and identify any recurring issues or concerns.
  • Security: Consumer Reports evaluates the security measures implemented by BNPL companies to protect consumers’ personal and financial information. Data breaches and fraud prevention strategies are key considerations in this assessment.
  • Cost and Fees: The cost structure of each BNPL company is thoroughly examined, including any fees or penalties associated with missed or late payments. This analysis helps consumers understand the potential financial implications of using a particular BNPL service.
  • Customer Support: The quality and availability of customer support provided by BNPL companies are also taken into account. Prompt and efficient assistance is essential for resolving any issues or concerns that customers may encounter during their BNPL experience.

Factors Considered in Ranking

Based on the methodology outlined above, Consumer Reports ranks BNPL companies using a weighted scoring system. The following factors are considered in the ranking process:

  • Clarity of Terms and Conditions: The clarity and transparency of a company’s terms and conditions play a significant role in its ranking. Consumer Reports examines the readability and accessibility of these terms, ensuring they are fair and not overly complex.
  • User Feedback and Satisfaction: Real consumer feedback, including reviews and ratings, is a crucial component of the ranking process. The experiences and opinions shared by users provide valuable insights into the overall satisfaction levels associated with each BNPL company.
  • Security and Privacy Measures: The protection of personal and financial information is of paramount importance. BNPL companies that prioritize data security and implement robust privacy measures receive higher rankings.
  • Cost and Fees: The cost structure, including fees and penalties, is carefully evaluated. BNPL services with reasonable fees and transparent cost structures receive higher rankings.
  • Customer Support: The accessibility and quality of customer support are considered in the ranking process. Companies that offer responsive and helpful customer service are rewarded with higher rankings.

Consumer Reports’ Top-Ranked Buy Now, Pay Later Companies

While Consumer Reports regularly updates its rankings, here are some of the top-ranked buy now, pay later companies based on their evaluation:


  • Purchase limit of $17,500
  • Soft credit check to prequalify
  • Payments of three, six, or 12 months are typical
  • This BNPL company received high rankings for its exceptional transparency, clear terms, and reasonable fees


  • Credit limits vary
  • Soft credit check
  • Four payments over six weeks
  • Known for its strong emphasis on data security and privacy, Sezzle has received positive rankings for its robust security measures and commitment to protecting customer information.

Paypal Pay in 4

  • Per transaction limit of $1,500
  • Soft credit check may be needed
  • Four equal payments
  • With a focus on customer satisfaction, Paypal has garnered high ratings for its responsive customer support and user-friendly interface.


  • Credit limits start at $500
  • Soft credit check, no minimum score
  • Purchases are split into four equal payments
  • This BNPL company stands out for its competitive cost structure, offering attractive terms and minimal fees compared to its competitors.

It’s important to note that rankings may vary over time as new BNPL companies emerge and existing ones make changes to their policies and practices. Consumer Reports regularly updates its evaluations to provide consumers with the most accurate and up-to-date information.

Benefits and Considerations of Using Buy Now, Pay Later Services

Buy now, pay later services offer several advantages to consumers, including:

  • Flexibility: BNPL allows consumers to make purchases without paying the full amount upfront, providing greater flexibility and budget management.
  • Interest-Free Installments: Unlike credit cards, BNPL services often offer interest-free installment plans, making it a cost-effective alternative for spreading out payments.
  • Accessibility: BNPL services are generally more accessible than traditional credit cards, as they often have more lenient approval criteria and do not require a lengthy application process.

However, it’s important for consumers to consider the following factors when using BNPL services:

  • Overspending: The ease of using BNPL services may lead some consumers to overspend or accumulate debt if they are not careful with their purchasing habits.
  • Late Fees and Penalties: Missing or delaying payments can result in late fees and penalties, potentially increasing the overall cost of the purchase.
  • Impact on Credit Score: While most BNPL services do not perform a hard credit check during the application process, missed payments or defaults can negatively impact a consumer’s credit score.
  • Responsible Usage: Consumers should use BNPL services responsibly and ensure they can comfortably meet the payment obligations within the agreed-upon timeframe.

Consumer Reports plays a vital role in evaluating and ranking buy now, pay later companies based on factors such as transparency, customer satisfaction, security, cost structure, and customer support. By providing consumers with this information, Consumer Reports empowers them to make informed decisions when choosing a BNPL service. It’s important for consumers to weigh the benefits and considerations of using BNPL services, ensuring responsible usage and maintaining financial well-being. As the popularity of BNPL continues to grow, the rankings provided by Consumer Reports serve as a valuable resource for individuals seeking reliable and trustworthy BNPL options. Which BNPL App do you mostly use? Share them in the comments below.